Senior Seminar in Criminal Justice

Instructions

Discussion Question Prompt:"By analyzing shaming and other innovative punishment schemes with regard to dignity, mental anguish, and arbitrariness; questions arise if these types of sanctions violate an individuals Eighth Amendment right, banning cruel and unusual punishment. What do you think of a judge who sanctions a convicted drunk driver, to display a sign on his or her car indicating they are a convicted drunk driver? Do you think a judge should be allowed the discretion to pronounce such a sentence? Do you believe shaming could reduce crime? Use information and empirical evidence from the lecture slides and reading assignment to support your position."Resource:Worrall, J., L. (2019). Crime Control in America: What Works? Fourth Edition. Pearson Education, Inc. United States of America.

Answer

Drinking and driving is a serious offense. It may lead to accidents, loss of life or even leaving a person in critical condition. However, a judge sanctioning a convicted drunk driver to display a sign on his/her car, indicating that they are convicted drunk driver, may not be the most reasonably humane way to pass a judgement (Worrall, 2018). Even though the ruling may prove to be effective because of its shaming nature, it has more tragic effects on both the convicted drunk driver as his/her dignity is tarnished and also to the family members. Therefore, the judge should be more considerate when passing such a verdict, bearing in mind that passing such a shaming judgement might indirectly cause more harm to innocent individuals.Nonetheless, I believe that a judge should be allowed the di...
To avoid plagiarism, part of the answer is hidden. Click on the button below to order the full answer.
Order Answer Back
Price Calculator
Manage orders
Why we are Ranked the best
  • Unlimited Revisions
  • Free 24/7 Support and chat
  • Money back guaranteed
  • Low prices with discounts
  • Experienced writers.
  • Free Unlimited support

Hear from our customers

Get a quote Chat with support Find an expert Frequently asked questions